WebsiteTherapy
Industry9 min readBy Lee Shadle

Why Headway Always Shows the Same Therapists, and How to Make Sure You Are Not a Ghost Listing

Headway shows the same therapists because a search returns everyone who matches a client's plan, location and filters, and refreshing returns that same set. Some of those names are not really taking clients. Here is why, what the directory investigations found, and how to check that your own listings tell the truth about your availability.

Why Headway Keeps Showing the Same Therapists

New names appear only when something underneath changes: a therapist joins, a therapist reopens to new clients, or the client changes a filter.

The second half of the problem is the part clients complain about most. Some of the names that keep coming back are not really taking new clients. Their status says they are; their caseload says otherwise. That gap has a name, the ghost network, and it is where your own listings come in.

This page is written for you, the therapist on the other side of that search. It covers how the pool gets small, what the government investigations into directory accuracy found, and how to check that every listing and AI answer about your practice shows your real availability.

The Filters That Set the Pool

Headway asks a client for a location and an insurance plan before it shows anyone. Each answer narrows the list, and the narrowing compounds.

  • The plan, not the carrier. A carrier sells many plans, and a therapist can be in network for some of them and not others. A client searching with one specific plan sees only the therapists contracted for that plan.
  • The state, not the country. Licensure is by state, so a client generally sees only therapists licensed where the client is. For in-person care, the radius shrinks again to a reasonable drive.
  • The specialty a therapist listed, not the training they have. A client who filters by a specialty sees only the therapists who listed it. A therapist trained in an approach but who never added it to the profile does not appear in that search.
  • The status, not the caseload. An "accepting new clients" status is only as current as the last time someone changed it.

Put those together in a small metro, add a narrow specialty, and the matching set can be a handful of people. The client has seen all of them by the second visit.

In what order those people appear is Headway's decision, and we could not find a public explanation of it from Headway. What does not depend on the ordering is the size of the set: refreshing does not add anyone who does not match.

Ghost Listings: What the Directory Investigations Found

A ghost network is a provider directory full of listings that do not lead to care: a therapist who is unreachable, no longer in network, or not accepting new patients. The two secret-shopper studies below, by the New York Attorney General and the Senate Finance Committee, found that more than 80% of the listings they called were ghosts, and a federal audit found more than half of listed providers saw no plan members in a year.

InvestigationWhat it checkedWhat it found
New York Attorney General, December 2023396 mental health providers listed by 13 health plans86% were unreachable, not in network, or not accepting new patients; 56 providers, or 14%, offered an appointment
Senate Finance Committee majority staff, May 2023120 mental health listings across 12 Medicare Advantage plans in 6 statesAn appointment was possible for 22 listings (18%); more than 80% were ghosts
HHS Office of Inspector General, 2025 (as reported by Behavioral Healthcare Network)40 Medicare Advantage plans and 20 Medicaid managed-care plans in 10 countiesOn average 55% of listed behavioral health providers had no encounters with plan members in 2023
New York Attorney General and EmblemHealth, February 2026Behavioral health providers EmblemHealth listed as accepting new patientsMore than 80% were effectively unavailable; the settlement was more than $2.5 million

The New York Attorney General's December 2023 report called 396 mental health providers listed by 13 plans and found 86% were unreachable, not in network, or not accepting new patients, with only 56 providers, or 14%, offering an appointment.

The Senate Finance Committee's May 2023 secret-shopper study called 10 providers from each of 12 Medicare Advantage plans in 6 states. Of those 120 listings, the report counts 39 (33%) as non-working numbers, incorrect numbers or calls never returned, and staff could make an appointment for only 22 (18%). Appointment rates ran from 0% in Oregon to 50% in Colorado, according to its executive summary. The staff counted six calls routed to a third-party matching service as appointments; without them, the report says, the rate falls to 16 of 120, or 13%.

Out of 120 Medicare Advantage mental health listings called, 22 led to an appointment Three bars on one scale starting at zero. 120 listings were called. 81 reached a working, correct number that answered or called back. 22 led to an appointment, 18 percent of the listings. 120 listings called 81 reached a working, correct number that answered 22 led to an appointment (18%) Senate Finance Committee majority staff, secret-shopper study of 12 Medicare Advantage plans, May 2023
Of 120 listed mental health providers the Senate Finance Committee staff called, 81 reached a working, correct number and 22 led to an appointment.

According to the HHS Office of Inspector General, as reported by Behavioral Healthcare Network, an average of 55% of the behavioral health providers listed by 40 Medicare Advantage plans and 20 Medicaid managed-care plans in 10 counties had no encounters with plan members during 2023. The sample was not nationally representative.

The Government Accountability Office's March 2022 report on mental health access found that inaccurate or out-of-date network information contributes to the problem, and that 19 of the 29 stakeholder organizations it contacted said low reimbursement rates contribute too.

These studies looked at insurer directories, not at Headway. Headway is a different kind of listing: a billing platform with its own client search. But the mechanism is the same one. A listing says a therapist is available, the therapist is not, and the client finds out only after reaching out. For more on the Medicare side of this, see Medicare Advantage and Mental Health: The Ghost Network Problem.

Where Your Own Listing Fits

Clients describe ghost networks as something done to them by insurers. From the other side, a ghost listing is usually a busy therapist who filled up and did not get to the paperwork.

It happens in ordinary ways. Your caseload fills in a month and your status still says open. You leave a plan and the insurer keeps you listed. You stop renewing a directory profile and an old copy stays up. You move offices and the old address lives on in three places. None of it is deliberate, and every one of them puts your name on a list that a client works through before giving up.

A therapist whose caseload is full but whose Headway profile, Psychology Today listing or insurer directory still says "accepting new clients" is one of the ghost entries clients keep hitting. WebsiteTherapy checks what ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI say about a practice and drafts a fix for anything that is wrong or out of date.

AI answers add a layer that did not exist a few years ago. When someone asks ChatGPT or Perplexity whether a named therapist is taking new clients, the answer is built from pages the system found. An answer built from an old directory page repeats the old page. For how those answers choose their sources, see How ChatGPT Recommends Therapists.

The cost runs both ways. A client who reaches a closed therapist loses a week.

How to Check What Directories and AI Answers Say About Your Availability

This takes an afternoon the first time and a few minutes a month after that.

  1. List every place you appear. Each insurer you are paneled with (their directories are separate), Headway or any other billing platform, Psychology Today and other therapist directories, your Google Business Profile, and your own website.
  2. Read each listing as a client would. Check the accepting-new-clients status, the plans, the address, the phone number and the specialties. Write down every one that is wrong.
  3. Ask the AI answers. Ask ChatGPT and Perplexity, and search Google, whether you are accepting new clients, using your name and your practice name. Note what each one says and which pages it cites. Fix the cited page, not the answer.
  4. Change your status the day your caseload changes, everywhere. Closing on Headway and leaving Psychology Today open makes you a ghost on one of them.
  5. Remove, not pause, what you have left. When you leave a plan or a platform, ask for the listing to be taken down rather than marked unavailable.
  6. Date your availability on your own site. One line on your contact page, such as "Accepting new clients as of October 2026," gives a client, and any system reading the page, the current answer and the date it was true.

Repeat steps 2 and 3 monthly. If you are deciding which directories are worth keeping at all, Are Therapist Directories Worth It in 2026? goes through the trade-offs, and our Psychology Today comparison covers the largest one.

Regulators Now Put a Clock on Directory Fixes

In February 2026 the New York Attorney General secured more than $2.5 million from EmblemHealth after finding that more than 80% of the surveyed behavioral health providers Emblem listed as accepting new patients were effectively unavailable. Under the settlement, Emblem must correct a listing within two business days of learning it is wrong or that a provider is no longer accepting new patients, require providers to verify their directory information every 90 days, and remove providers who fail to verify or are no longer available.

The settlement binds EmblemHealth, not Headway or any other platform. What it shows is where the burden is heading: onto the provider, on a schedule, with removal as the penalty for silence. A therapist who already keeps every listing current has nothing to change when a plan sends that 90-day request.

What the Same Names Mean for You as a Headway Therapist

If you are on Headway and open to new clients, you are one of the names a client keeps seeing. That is a small pool, and it works for you only if your status is true. If you are closed, the most useful thing you can do for that pool is to say so.

A client who works through the same names and finds no opening does not stop needing a therapist. Some go back to their insurer's directory, some ask a friend, and some type the question into Google or an AI assistant. A practice with its own accurate website and listings can be found in those places as itself, not as one row in a platform's list.

That is a choice about where your clients come from, not a verdict on Headway. If you are weighing it against running your own intake, our Headway comparison sets out the trade-off, and Therapist Platform Consolidation: 2026 Guide covers how the billing platforms are changing.

Next Step

The checklist above is yours to run; we don't manage directory listings. What WebsiteTherapy adds, for the practices we host, is the AI side: it checks what ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI say about the practice and drafts a fix for anything they get wrong. The features page sets out what it covers. Which corrections to make, and when, stays your decision.

Ready to make your practice AI-discoverable?

Book a free consultation — we'll show you how AI sees your practice today.

Prefer to write? Send us a message