Headway vs Alma vs Grow Therapy: A Therapist's Comparison
Headway, Alma and Grow Therapy compared for therapists: what each pays and charges, who holds the insurance contract, and what Headway's new $9.99 fee costs at a full caseload.
Headway vs Alma vs Grow Therapy: the short answer
Headway, Alma and Grow Therapy all get you in-network with insurers, file the claims and pay you on a schedule. The biggest difference is what each pays you, so get three rate sheets first. After that the fees differ: Alma bills a membership, Headway is adding $9.99 per appointment for marketplace clients, and Grow Therapy's self-reported pay is lowest.
If the rates you are offered come back close:
- Pick Alma if you want one fixed cost for the year and you expect most new clients to come through the network.
- Pick Headway if most of your clients find you on their own. Those sessions carry no marketplace fee.
- Pick Grow Therapy if being paid every Friday matters more to you than the rate.
I run WebsiteTherapy. We are not an insurance network. We do sell a website you would run beside any of the three, so weigh that when I get to it. Unless I name another source, everything below comes from the three companies' own pages as they read on November 12, 2026. Where something is not on those pages, I say so.
How do Headway, Alma and Grow Therapy compare side by side?
Three terms first. Credentialing is an insurer approving you to bill it in-network. A rate sheet is the list of what you will be paid for each session code by each insurer. A marketplace client is one the network's own search or ads sent you.
| Headway | Alma | Grow Therapy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost to join | No membership fee. Credentialing is free. (Credentialing page.) | A membership fee. No price on the Alma pages read. Therapist Rates and Choosing Therapy report $125 a month or $1,140 a year. Therapist Rates adds that tax is extra. | I found no membership fee on the Grow pages read. |
| What it keeps on insurance sessions | "a small percentage of session payments", no figure given (earnings page, June 2024). Plus $9.99 per appointment with new marketplace clients, state by state (help article, updated November 2, 2026). | Not on the pages read. | Not on the pages read. Grow says the rate on your rate sheet is the full amount you are paid (payout FAQ). |
| Private-pay sessions | The $9.99 fee also applies to private-pay sessions with marketplace clients. Therapist Rates reports a 2.95% fee on private-pay sessions. I could not read that on a Headway page. | Alma says it takes no cut of cash-pay visits (provider page). | A 5% processing fee on cash-pay appointment payments (help article, August 7, 2026). Payments must run through Grow. |
| Pay schedule | Twice a month, on the 15th and the last day (help article, updated January 14, 2026). | Typically within two weeks of a session. Not worded as a guarantee (Alma vs Headway page). | Payouts start every Friday and typically reach your bank in 1 to 3 business days (payout FAQ). |
| Denied claims and unpaid client balances | "If a claim is denied, we absorb that risk, not you." (earnings page, June 2024). | A client invoice unpaid after 60 days is deducted from your payout (Membership Overview). | Insurance payouts are guaranteed even if Grow cannot collect from the insurer or the client. Cash-pay and no-show fees are not (session payment article). |
| Credentialing time | "in as few as 30 days" (credentialing page). | Under 45 days (provider page). | 5 to 7 days on average with Grow. Some insurers take 2 months or more, and some go beyond 6 months (enrollment FAQ, updated August 30, 2026). |
| Whose contract | Not on the pages read. | You are credentialed under Alma's tax ID, even if you already hold your own credentials (FAQ). | You are added to Grow's group contracts (enrollment FAQ). |
| If you leave | Not on the pages read. | Not on the pages read. | Your enrollment does not transfer outside Grow (enrollment FAQ). |
| Who can join | The credentialing page addresses therapists and psychiatrists. | Fully licensed clinicians only. New members must join the insurance program (FAQ). | Therapists and prescribers. You must be in-network with at least one insurer through Grow (enrollment FAQ). |
| Size | No current count on the pages read. | Spring Health gives a combined network of more than 40,000 providers (August 2026). No Alma-only figure. | "26,000+ clinicians" (provider page). 125+ insurer partners, including Medicare and Medicaid in most states (Series D post, 2026). |
| Owner | Venture-backed (funding reports, 2024). | Part of Spring Health since May 1, 2026. Alma has told providers its pricing and contracts are not changing. | Venture-backed (funding reports, 2026). |
Cells with no date were read on November 12, 2026. The pages are listed under "What I checked and how".
All three describe practice tools. Alma lists a video platform and an integrated EHR, Grow Therapy lists an EHR, scheduling and telehealth, and Headway describes practice-management tools with note templates. I left tools out of the table because they should not decide this for you.
Which pays more: Headway, Alma or Grow Therapy?
I found no rates on any of the three sites. You see your own rate sheet after you apply. Barbara Griswold, a consultant, told ClearHealthCosts in November 2025 that a clinician typically has to go through the contract process before learning the rate.
The only side-by-side figures I found are self-reported. On Therapist Rates on November 12, 2026, the self-reported median for a 60-minute session (CPT 90837) was $118 on Headway (164 reports), $110 on Alma (55 reports) and $88 on Grow Therapy (38 reports). The middle half of reports ran $98 to $127 on Headway, $103 to $120 on Alma and $74 to $95 on Grow Therapy.
The site labels its own figures as self-reported and unverified, and they are not matched by state or license. I would not treat an $8 gap between Headway and Alma as real. A gap of $22 to $30 between Grow Therapy and the other two is large enough to take seriously, and at a full caseload it would outweigh every fee discussed below.
The order also changes by insurer. The same site's medians, with the number of reports behind each:
| Insurer | Headway | Alma | Grow Therapy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aetna | $129 (55) | $120 (16) | $95 (7) |
| Optum / UnitedHealthcare | $118 (20) | $117 (18) | $93 (5) |
| Cigna | $95 (22) | $102 (11) | $73 (5) |
| Blue Cross Blue Shield | $108 (52) | $107 (5) | $83 (6) |
On Cigna, Alma's reported median is above Headway's. Several cells rest on 5 to 7 reports, so read the table as a reason to ask, not as an answer.
Rates also move after you join, because insurers change them and the network passes the change on. Optum rates fell for clinicians on both Alma and Headway in late 2024, according to ClearHealthCosts and Behavioral Health Business. In 2026 Aetna changed what it pays Alma clinicians: Alma notified providers on May 20, with changes set to start July 15, according to the same two outlets. Neither report says Headway or Grow Therapy was affected.
So ask each network for the rate sheet for your license, your state and your two most common insurers before you sign anything. That number is worth more than any median.
What does each one cost you?
Alma charges a membership. Its provider pages say only that it charges "a monthly fee for membership", with no dollar figure. Therapist Rates (checked September 9, 2026) and Choosing Therapy (October 14, 2026) both report $125 a month, or $1,140 a year if you pay annually. Therapist Rates adds that tax is extra. Alma's help center adds that membership ends after 60 days if fees go unpaid, and that a client invoice left unpaid for 60 days "will be deducted from your payout".
A membership may not be the only cost. One Oregon counselor told ClearHealthCosts in November 2025 that on a United session the insurer paid $142.80 and she received $121.80. That is one person's account. The outlet says Alma did not respond, and I found nothing on Alma's pages about a share kept.
Headway charges nothing to join. Its own explanation of how it earns is that it keeps "a small percentage of session payments", and that the amount depends on the rates it negotiates. It gives no percentage.
The new cost is the marketplace service fee. Headway's help article, updated November 2, 2026, says: "It's $9.99 per appointment and the same amount for every health plan." It is deducted from your payout on sessions with new clients who first found you through Headway's marketplace. Headway is introducing it state by state with at least 7 days' notice, and the article lists no start dates. Which clients count, and which are exempt, is covered further down.
I found no membership fee on the Grow Therapy pages read, and nothing on how it earns on insurance sessions. Its help center lists a 5% processing fee on cash-pay appointment payments, and a 1.5% charge, paid to Stripe, if you want an instant payout before Friday.
What Headway's $9.99 fee adds up to
Take a therapist who sees 20 insurance clients a week for 48 weeks. That is 960 sessions a year. The fee depends on how many of those sessions are with marketplace clients who started after the fee reached that state:
The same figures as text: $0 with no marketplace clients, $2,397.60 a year at one session in four, $4,795.20 at half and $9,590.40 at every session. Alma's reported membership is $1,140 a year paid annually, or $1,500 paid month to month, whatever your caseload. At 960 sessions that is $1.19 or $1.56 a session.
Headway's $9.99 marketplace fee costs more than Alma's reported $1,140 annual membership from the 115th session a year with marketplace clients, about 2.4 a week. Against Alma's month-to-month price the crossover is the 151st session. One marketplace client seen weekly for 48 weeks costs $479.52.
This compares the two fees you can see. It leaves out any share a network keeps of what the insurer pays, because I could not find one stated. Put the fee next to the pay figures above: Headway's reported median of $118 less $9.99 is $108.01, which is below Alma's reported $110 and still well above Grow Therapy's $88.
Who holds the insurance contract, and what happens when you leave?
On Alma and Grow Therapy, the insurer's contract is with the network, and you work inside it. A group contract means claims go out under the network's tax ID, not yours.
- Alma: members are credentialed under Alma's tax ID, whatever credentials they already hold on their own. New members are credentialed with at least one of Aetna, Cigna or Optum.
- Grow Therapy: enrollment adds you to Grow's group contracts. Asked whether enrollment carries over if you leave, Grow's help center answers that it will not transfer outside of Grow.
- Headway: the pages read do not say. Choosing Therapy's October 2026 comparison reports that Headway bills under a Type 2 (group) NPI.
For Grow Therapy that is explicit: when you leave, you are no longer in-network through Grow. For the other two I could not find it stated. Carepatron, a practice-software vendor, says in-network status usually does not transfer and that being credentialed again under your own NPI commonly takes 60 to 180 days per insurer. That is a vendor's estimate, but plan around it until an insurer tells you otherwise. If you think you may leave within a couple of years, start your own credentialing with your two biggest insurers before you give notice.
Can you take your clients with you? None of the pages read answers that directly. Alma's published rule covers referrals: "All consultation requests and referrals sourced through Alma should stay in the Alma network." Grow Therapy's covers payments: "All payments, including session charges and refunds, must be processed exclusively through the Grow platform". Ask each network in writing what applies to clients it referred and to clients you brought.
None of the three states a notice period for leaving on the pages read. Alma's help center lists articles on canceling and pausing a membership, and I did not read their contents. The agreement you sign is what binds you, so ask for it and read the termination section first.
One more term to know: a recoupment is an insurer taking back money it already paid. Grow Therapy says it absorbs insurer-initiated recoupments. It also says a rebilled claim can change your rate, with the adjustment taken from your next payout.
Where do your clients come from, and what does Headway's fee change?
This used to be a soft question. Headway's fee has put a price on it.
Headway now sorts every new client by how they first found you, and the label never changes: "it stays the same for all your sessions with them after that." A client counts as a marketplace client, and carries the $9.99 fee, if they found you through:
- Headway's marketplace matching
- a Headway ad
- Headway's booking team
- a connected partner, including health plans and health systems
- "Headway's AI integrations, like ChatGPT"
Headway's article lists these sessions as carrying no fee:
- "Clients you add yourself, using Add Client or your calendar"
- "Clients who book with you through your direct link (you can find this in your Profile settings), wherever you've shared it (for example, your Psychology Today profile, website, or email signature)"
- "Clients who come straight to your profile on their first visit, from a search engine (not an ad) or by searching your name on Headway"
- "Clients you started seeing before the fee started in your primary practice state, however they found you"
For a marketplace client the fee applies "for as long as you see that client, not just their first session." You can switch off your appearance in the marketplace. Clients who already came through it after your state's start date keep the fee.
So on Headway the cheapest new client is one who was looking for you by name. Put your direct link on your own website, your Psychology Today profile and your email signature before the fee reaches your state. I cover the limits of relying on Headway's own search in why Headway keeps showing the same therapists.
I found no per-client marketplace fee on the Alma or Grow Therapy pages read, so the source of a client should not change your pay there. It still decides who the client belongs to in practice. Alma asks that referrals it sources stay in its network. In four Grow Therapy profiles I read on November 12, 2026, none linked to the therapist's own website or showed the therapist's own phone number or email. Four profiles is a spot check, and I could not read Headway or Alma profiles the same way, so it is not a comparison.
Your own site also matters when people ask an AI assistant instead of a directory. In WebsiteTherapy's October 2026 check, we asked three AI assistants 155 local questions on behalf of 11 US therapy practices, and the practice was named in 39 of the 155 answers (25%). When an answer did name the practice, it linked the practice's own website in 32 of those 39 answers, across 7 practices. None of that data names Headway, Alma or Grow Therapy. The practices are not a random sample and the questions went through the assistants' APIs, so the rate for all practices may well be lower.
Whichever network you join, a site you own is the one place a client who already wants you can reach you with no network in between. Our pages on Headway, Alma and Grow Therapy each cover running one beside the network. Ours is $99 a month with no setup fee and no contract. Yours does not have to be ours.
Which should you pick?
Start with pay, because it is the largest number. Get the rate sheet from each network for your license and state. If one pays $20 a session more than the others for your main insurers, that settles most of it: at 960 sessions a year, $20 a session is $19,200.
If the rates come back close, the pairs below are how I would decide.
Headway vs Alma
This one turns on where your clients come from. If most of them will arrive through the network's own search, Alma's fixed membership is the cheaper visible fee once you pass about 115 marketplace sessions a year. If most already find you by name, by referral or through your own site, Headway charges no visible fee for them.
The other differences I could verify: Headway pays twice a month, and Alma typically within two weeks of a session. Alma credentials you under its own tax ID, and I could not find who holds the contract on the Headway pages read. Alma accepts fully licensed clinicians only.
Headway vs Grow Therapy
Here the reported pay gap is the widest of the three pairs, about $30 a session in Headway's favor on self-reported medians, which is more than Headway's new fee. Grow Therapy's case is cash flow and certainty: it pays every Friday and guarantees the insurance payout even when it cannot collect. If you are building a caseload from zero and need predictable weekly income, that can be worth a lower rate for a while.
Two more differences: Headway pays twice a month against Grow Therapy's weekly payouts. And Grow Therapy says your enrollment does not transfer if you leave, while I could not find exit terms on the Headway pages read.
Alma vs Grow Therapy
Alma costs a membership whether or not you have clients yet, and its reported pay is about $22 a session higher. Grow Therapy shows no fee on insurance sessions and a 5% processing fee on cash-pay ones. With a full caseload the reported pay difference is far larger than Alma's membership. With a handful of clients, Grow Therapy's lack of a fixed cost matters more.
Both put the insurance contract with the network: Alma under its tax ID, Grow Therapy under its group contracts. Alma typically pays within two weeks of a session, and Grow Therapy starts payouts every Friday. Alma accepts fully licensed clinicians only, and Grow Therapy also lists requirements for prescribers.
If your situation is different
- You already hold contracts with insurers directly. Alma credentials you under its own tax ID regardless. Ask each network how it handles an insurer you already bill yourself, and compare its rate sheet with what you are paid now.
- You plan to go independent within two years. Weight the exit terms most. Grow Therapy says enrollment does not transfer, and I could not find exit terms for the other two. Start your own credentialing early.
- Part of your caseload is private pay. Alma says it takes no cut of cash-pay sessions. Grow Therapy lists a 5% processing fee and requires payments to run through its platform. Headway's $9.99 applies to private-pay sessions with marketplace clients, and Therapist Rates reports a 2.95% fee on private-pay sessions that I could not read on a Headway page.
- You are happy on a network and have no plan to leave. Then exit terms matter less to you and pay should decide. One counselor quoted by ClearHealthCosts in November 2025 said his Headway clients pay him 20% to 30% better. If a network pays you more than you can get elsewhere, that outweighs everything in the two sections above.
For the wider decision of whether to take insurance at all, see should therapists accept insurance. If you are weighing Alma against building a private-pay caseload, see getting private-pay clients without Alma.
What I checked and how
Company pages, as they read on November 12, 2026:
- Headway (read in a browser): the help articles Understanding the marketplace service fee (updated November 2, 2026) and Getting paid (updated January 14, 2026), the page Where Headway's earnings come from (dated June 14, 2024) and the credentialing page.
- Alma: the help article Membership Overview and the insurance page (read in a browser), and the provider page, the FAQ, Alma's own Alma vs Headway page and its post on the Spring Health acquisition (read through an automated page reader).
- Grow Therapy: the provider page and the session payment article (read in a browser), and the help articles on payouts, cash-pay appointments, enrollment and credentialing and revenue cycle management, plus its Series D post (automated reader).
I also searched Headway's and Alma's help centers for articles on leaving. Headway's search returned nothing I could read on it. Alma's returned articles on canceling and pausing a membership, by title only.
Text in quotation marks comes from the pages read in a browser. Where a page came through the automated reader, I paraphrase.
Other sources, each named where it is used: Therapist Rates for Alma's price and the pay medians, Choosing Therapy's October 2026 comparisons, Spring Health's posts of May 1 and August 4, 2026, Behavioral Health Business and ClearHealthCosts for the insurer rate changes and therapists' accounts, and Carepatron for the credentialing estimate.
Not on any page read, for any of the three: a notice period for leaving, or a stated share kept of what insurers pay beyond Headway's "small percentage". Not on the Headway pages: state start dates for the fee, exit terms, who holds the contract. Not on the Alma pages: a dollar price for membership, or what happens to your credentialing when you leave. Not on the Grow Therapy pages: how it earns on insurance sessions, or its provider agreement. I did not read any provider agreement.
The Grow Therapy profile check was four public profiles, read as page text. The AI figures come from WebsiteTherapy's own check of October 2 to 5, 2026, described in how often AI assistants name a therapy practice. The cost arithmetic assumes 20 sessions a week for 48 weeks and uses only the two fees that are published or reported.
These terms change. Headway's fee article has been edited several times since October 2026, according to Therapist Rates, which tracks it. I will re-read all three sets of pages when Headway publishes state dates and note the new date here.
Common questions
Is Headway free for therapists?
Headway charges no membership or credentialing fee. It keeps an undisclosed "small percentage" of session payments and is introducing a $9.99 fee per appointment with new clients who found you through its marketplace.
Do I own my insurance contracts on Headway, Alma or Grow Therapy?
You do not hold the insurance contract on Alma or Grow Therapy. Alma credentials you under its tax ID and Grow Therapy adds you to its group contracts. The Headway pages I read do not say.
What happens to my insurance panels if I leave?
Grow Therapy says your enrollment does not transfer outside Grow. I could not find this stated on Alma's or Headway's pages. Plan on being out-of-network until you are credentialed under your own name.
Can I be on more than one of these at once?
I did not check this with any of the three. The pages read say this much: Alma credentials members under its own tax ID whatever credentials they already hold, and Grow Therapy requires you to be in-network with at least one insurer through Grow. Ask each network how it handles an insurer you already bill through another.